Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2024 December 12: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→Bruce_Hall_(musician): endorse |
→Bruce_Hall_(musician): e, but... |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
Unsure as to why Bruce's page got deleted, I am reaching out as a rep of Bruce. [[Special:Contributions/2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F|2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F]] ([[User talk:2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F|talk]]) 14:56, 12 December 2024 (UTC) |
Unsure as to why Bruce's page got deleted, I am reaching out as a rep of Bruce. [[Special:Contributions/2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F|2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F]] ([[User talk:2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F|talk]]) 14:56, 12 December 2024 (UTC) |
||
*'''Endorse''' as a reasonable close and the only reasonable close of the deletion discussion. It was [[WP:BLAR|redirected]] in place of deletion because the separate article was inadequately sourced and did not support individual [[WP:NMUSIC|musical notability]] apart from the band. Any editor may submit a more complete draft for review, with [[WP:RS|reliable sources]] and providing information beyond his role in [[REO Speedwagon]], provided that any [[WP:COI|conflict of interest]] must be declared. [[User:Robert McClenon|Robert McClenon]] ([[User talk:Robert McClenon|talk]]) 20:04, 12 December 2024 (UTC) |
*'''Endorse''' as a reasonable close and the only reasonable close of the deletion discussion. It was [[WP:BLAR|redirected]] in place of deletion because the separate article was inadequately sourced and did not support individual [[WP:NMUSIC|musical notability]] apart from the band. Any editor may submit a more complete draft for review, with [[WP:RS|reliable sources]] and providing information beyond his role in [[REO Speedwagon]], provided that any [[WP:COI|conflict of interest]] must be declared. [[User:Robert McClenon|Robert McClenon]] ([[User talk:Robert McClenon|talk]]) 20:04, 12 December 2024 (UTC) |
||
*'''Endorse''' A draft isn't necessary, nor is our permission to un-redirect and expand, provided a non-COI editor wants to do that--and there should be someone willing to. A draft is indeed the appropriate step for a COI editor. At the same time, I question the accuracy of the past AfD--it happened right as REO Speedwagon was in the news for the Hall/Cronin rift and cessation of touring, and I see plenty of Google News coverage for Hall--there's no question in my mind that at the time of the AfD there was an adequate amount of sourcing for Hall's individual notability, and the AfD outcome, though clear, was wrong on the merits. [[User:Jclemens|Jclemens]] ([[User talk:Jclemens|talk]]) 20:13, 12 December 2024 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 20:13, 12 December 2024
Unsure as to why Bruce's page got deleted, I am reaching out as a rep of Bruce. 2601:5CD:C100:DA10:B0AA:52CB:1381:B68F (talk) 14:56, 12 December 2024 (UTC)
- Endorse as a reasonable close and the only reasonable close of the deletion discussion. It was redirected in place of deletion because the separate article was inadequately sourced and did not support individual musical notability apart from the band. Any editor may submit a more complete draft for review, with reliable sources and providing information beyond his role in REO Speedwagon, provided that any conflict of interest must be declared. Robert McClenon (talk) 20:04, 12 December 2024 (UTC)
- Endorse A draft isn't necessary, nor is our permission to un-redirect and expand, provided a non-COI editor wants to do that--and there should be someone willing to. A draft is indeed the appropriate step for a COI editor. At the same time, I question the accuracy of the past AfD--it happened right as REO Speedwagon was in the news for the Hall/Cronin rift and cessation of touring, and I see plenty of Google News coverage for Hall--there's no question in my mind that at the time of the AfD there was an adequate amount of sourcing for Hall's individual notability, and the AfD outcome, though clear, was wrong on the merits. Jclemens (talk) 20:13, 12 December 2024 (UTC)