Jump to content

Indian vulture crisis: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
OAbot (talk | contribs)
Bots
439,234 edits
m Open access bot: doi updated in citation with #oabot.
m formatting, replaced: “ → ", ” → ", typo(s) fixed: 2020-25 → 2020–25
Line 6: Line 6:
|publisher=IUCN |access-date=13 August 2015 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140627094911/http://www.iucnredlist.org/ |archive-date=June 27, 2014}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.sospecies.org/sos_projects/birds/vultures_india/|title=Conserving South Asia's Threatened Vultures|publisher=Save Our Species|access-date=13 August 2015}}</ref> In the early 1980s, three species of ''[[Gyps]]'' vultures (the [[white-rumped vulture]], the [[long-billed vulture]] and the [[slender-billed vulture]]) had a combined estimated population of 40 million in South Asia, while in 2017 the total population numbered only 19,000 (6,000, 12,000, and 1,000 respectively).
|publisher=IUCN |access-date=13 August 2015 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140627094911/http://www.iucnredlist.org/ |archive-date=June 27, 2014}}</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.sospecies.org/sos_projects/birds/vultures_india/|title=Conserving South Asia's Threatened Vultures|publisher=Save Our Species|access-date=13 August 2015}}</ref> In the early 1980s, three species of ''[[Gyps]]'' vultures (the [[white-rumped vulture]], the [[long-billed vulture]] and the [[slender-billed vulture]]) had a combined estimated population of 40 million in South Asia, while in 2017 the total population numbered only 19,000 (6,000, 12,000, and 1,000 respectively).


With a loss of over 99% of all the population of vultures, the Indian vulture crisis represents the sharpest decline of any animal in the given period.<ref>{{Cite news|url=https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/sharp-decline-in-vulture-population-from-40-million-to-19000-prakash-javadekar/article28586530.ece|title=Sharp decline in vulture population, from 40 million to 19,000: Prakash Javadekar|newspaper=[[The Hindu]]|date=19 July 2019|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> A major contributing factor in declining populations of vultures is believed to be the widespread use of drugs such as [[diclofenac]], a [[nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug]] (NSAID) once commonly given to livestock. The drug is believed to have been passed onto the vultures through the flesh of dead cattle who were given diclofenac in their last days of life, which then causes [[kidney failure]] in vultures.<ref name="Cam">{{cite web|url=https://www.cambridge.org/core/blog/2022/09/28/south-asian-vultures-and-diclofenac/|title=South Asian vultures and diclofenac|author1=Ian Burfield|author2=Chris Bowden|date=28 September 2022|publisher=Cambridge University|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> Data modelling revealed that a tiny proportion (about 0.8%) of livestock carcasses containing diclofenac can cause significant crash in vulture populations.<ref name="Gu">{{cite news|url=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/aug/19/india-critically-endangered-vultures-wild-release-aoe|title=Born to be wild: India's first captive-bred endangered vultures set free|work=[[The Guardian]]|author=Kamakshi Iyer|date=19 August 2021|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>
With a loss of over 99% of all the population of vultures, the '''Indian vulture crisis''' represents the sharpest decline of any animal in the given period.<ref>{{Cite news|url=https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/sharp-decline-in-vulture-population-from-40-million-to-19000-prakash-javadekar/article28586530.ece|title=Sharp decline in vulture population, from 40 million to 19,000: Prakash Javadekar|newspaper=[[The Hindu]]|date=19 July 2019|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> A major contributing factor in declining populations of vultures is believed to be the widespread use of drugs such as [[diclofenac]], a [[nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug]] (NSAID) once commonly given to livestock. The drug is believed to have been passed onto the vultures through the flesh of dead cattle who were given diclofenac in their last days of life, which then causes [[kidney failure]] in vultures.<ref name="Cam">{{cite web|url=https://www.cambridge.org/core/blog/2022/09/28/south-asian-vultures-and-diclofenac/|title=South Asian vultures and diclofenac|author1=Ian Burfield|author2=Chris Bowden|date=28 September 2022|publisher=Cambridge University|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> Data modelling revealed that a tiny proportion (about 0.8%) of livestock carcasses containing diclofenac can cause significant crash in vulture populations.<ref name="Gu">{{cite news|url=https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/aug/19/india-critically-endangered-vultures-wild-release-aoe|title=Born to be wild: India's first captive-bred endangered vultures set free|work=[[The Guardian]]|author=Kamakshi Iyer|date=19 August 2021|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>


Without vultures, a large number of animal carcasses were left to rot, posing a serious risk to human health by providing a potential breeding ground for infectious germs and proliferation of pests such as rats.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Prakash |first1=V. |last2=Pain |first2=D.J. |last3=Cunningham |first3=A.A. |last4=Donald |first4=P.F. |last5=Prakash |first5=N. |last6=Verma |first6=A. |last7=Gargi |first7=R. |last8=Sivakumar |first8=S. |last9=Rahmani |first9=A.R. |name-list-style=amp |title=Catastrophic collapse of Indian white-backed ''Gyps bengalensis'' and long-billed ''Gyps indicus'' vulture populations |journal=Biological Conservation |date=2003|volume=109|issue=3 |pages=381–390 |doi=10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00164-7}}</ref> The loss of vultures also resulted in a substantial increase in the population of feral dogs, whose bites are the most common cause of human [[rabies]]. The feral dog population in India increased by least 5 million, resulting in over 38 million additional dog bites and more than 47,000 extra deaths from rabies, costing $34 billion in economic impact.<ref name="Cam"/>
Without vultures, a large number of animal carcasses were left to rot, posing a serious risk to human health by providing a potential breeding ground for infectious germs and proliferation of pests such as rats.<ref name="Catastrophic collapse of Indian whi">{{cite journal |last1=Prakash |first1=V. |last2=Pain |first2=D.J. |last3=Cunningham |first3=A.A. |last4=Donald |first4=P.F. |last5=Prakash |first5=N. |last6=Verma |first6=A. |last7=Gargi |first7=R. |last8=Sivakumar |first8=S. |last9=Rahmani |first9=A.R. |name-list-style=amp |title=Catastrophic collapse of Indian white-backed ''Gyps bengalensis'' and long-billed ''Gyps indicus'' vulture populations |journal=Biological Conservation |date=2003|volume=109|issue=3 |pages=381–390 |doi=10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00164-7}}</ref> The loss of vultures also resulted in a substantial increase in the population of feral dogs, whose bites are the most common cause of human [[rabies]]. The feral dog population in India increased by least 5 million, resulting in over 38 million additional dog bites and more than 47,000 extra deaths from rabies, costing $34 billion in economic impact.<ref name="Cam"/>


Veterinary usage of diclofenac has been banned in India since 2006.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.nhp.gov.in/Complete-list-of-344-drugs-banned-by-the-Ministry-of-Health-Family-welfare_pg|title=Diclofenac Ban}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.4vultures.org/2017/11/04/the-sanitary-workers-get-some-backup-in-india/|title=Indian courts ban multi-dose vials of Diclofenac – another step in the right direction to save Southern Asia vultures from extinction|date=4 November 2017|website=Vulture Conservation Foundation|language=en-US|access-date=25 June 2020}}</ref> [[Meloxicam]], another NSAID, which was rapidly metabolized and harmless to vultures, was suggested as an acceptable substitute for diclofenac.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1532045618301935|title=Percentage of faecal excretion of meloxicam in the Cape vultures (Gyps corprotheres)|date=1 January 2019|publisher=Science Direct|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> In addition, various conservation schemes are in place to help recover the vulture population.<ref name="Pr">{{cite news|last=Kinver|first=M. |title=Project targets 2016 for Asian vultures release|url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-25963100|access-date=2 February 2014 |newspaper=BBC News|date=31 Jan 2014}}</ref> The population is recovering slowly and the decline has been significantly arrested in India, Pakistan and Nepal following a strict ban on the drugs causing harm to the vultures.<ref name="BL">{{cite web|url=http://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/indian-vulture-gyps-indicus/details|title=Indian Vulture factsheet|access-date=25 August 2023|publisher=birdlife.org}}</ref><ref name="Cam"/><ref>{{cite news|url=https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/wildlife-biodiversity/madhya-pradesh-s-vulture-population-increases-62867|title=Madhya Pradesh's vulture population increases|author=Rajat Ghai|date=17 January 2019|publisher=[[Times of India]]|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>
Veterinary usage of diclofenac has been banned in India since 2006.<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.nhp.gov.in/Complete-list-of-344-drugs-banned-by-the-Ministry-of-Health-Family-welfare_pg|title=Diclofenac Ban}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.4vultures.org/2017/11/04/the-sanitary-workers-get-some-backup-in-india/|title=Indian courts ban multi-dose vials of Diclofenac – another step in the right direction to save Southern Asia vultures from extinction|date=4 November 2017|website=Vulture Conservation Foundation|language=en-US|access-date=25 June 2020}}</ref> [[Meloxicam]], another NSAID, which was rapidly metabolized and harmless to vultures, was suggested as an acceptable substitute for diclofenac.<ref name="Science Direct">{{cite web|url=https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1532045618301935|title=Percentage of faecal excretion of meloxicam in the Cape vultures (Gyps corprotheres)|date=1 January 2019|publisher=Science Direct|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> In addition, various conservation schemes are in place to help recover the vulture population.<ref name="Pr">{{cite news|last=Kinver|first=M. |title=Project targets 2016 for Asian vultures release|url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-25963100|access-date=2 February 2014 |newspaper=BBC News|date=31 Jan 2014}}</ref> The population is recovering slowly and the decline has been significantly arrested in India, Pakistan and Nepal following a strict ban on the drugs causing harm to the vultures.<ref name="BL">{{cite web|url=http://datazone.birdlife.org/species/factsheet/indian-vulture-gyps-indicus/details|title=Indian Vulture factsheet|access-date=25 August 2023|publisher=birdlife.org}}</ref><ref name="Cam"/><ref>{{cite news|url=https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/wildlife-biodiversity/madhya-pradesh-s-vulture-population-increases-62867|title=Madhya Pradesh's vulture population increases|author=Rajat Ghai|date=17 January 2019|publisher=[[Times of India]]|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>


==History==
==History==
Line 24: Line 24:


==Consequences==
==Consequences==
By removing all [[carrion]], vultures had helped decrease pollution, spread of diseases, and suppressed undesirable mammalian scavengers.<ref>{{Cite journal|last1=Prakash|first1=V. |last2=Bishwakarma|first2=M. C. |last3=Chaudhary |first3=A. |last4=Cuthbert |first4=R. |last5=Dave |first5=R. |last6=Kulkarni |first6=M. |last7=Kumar |first7=S. |last8=Paudel |first8=K. |last9=Ranade |first9=S. |name-list-style=amp |date=2012 |title=The Population Decline of Gyps Vultures in India and Nepal Has Slowed since Veterinary Use of Diclofenac was Banned |journal=PLOS ONE |volume=7 |issue=11 |pages=e49118 |doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0049118 |pmc=3492300 |pmid=23145090 |bibcode=2012PLoSO...749118P|doi-access=free }}</ref> The sudden collapse of the natural animal disposal system in India has had multiple consequences negatively impacting public health.<ref>{{Cite news |title=The sudden demise of Indian vultures killed thousands of people |newspaper=The Economist |url=https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2023/08/22/the-sudden-demise-of-indian-vultures-killed-thousands-of-people |access-date=23 August 2023|issn=0013-0613}}</ref> A vulture's [[metabolism]] is a true “dead-end” for pathogens, but dogs and rats become carriers of the pathogens.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.livescience.com/48899-vultures-bacteria-microbiome.html|title=Vultures bacteria biome|date=25 November 2014|publisher=livescience.com|access-date=18 February 2016}}</ref> Without vultures, a large number of animal carcasses were left to rot posing a serious risk to human health by providing a potential breeding ground for infectious germs and proliferation of pests such as rats.<ref>{{cite journal |last1=Prakash |first1=V. |last2=Pain |first2=D.J. |last3=Cunningham |first3=A.A. |last4=Donald |first4=P.F. |last5=Prakash |first5=N. |last6=Verma |first6=A. |last7=Gargi |first7=R. |last8=Sivakumar |first8=S. |last9=Rahmani |first9=A.R. |name-list-style=amp |title=Catastrophic collapse of Indian white-backed ''Gyps bengalensis'' and long-billed ''Gyps indicus'' vulture populations |journal=Biological Conservation |date=2003|volume=109|issue=3 |pages=381–390 |doi=10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00164-7}}</ref>
By removing all [[carrion]], vultures had helped decrease pollution, spread of diseases, and suppressed undesirable mammalian scavengers.<ref>{{Cite journal|last1=Prakash|first1=V. |last2=Bishwakarma|first2=M. C. |last3=Chaudhary |first3=A. |last4=Cuthbert |first4=R. |last5=Dave |first5=R. |last6=Kulkarni |first6=M. |last7=Kumar |first7=S. |last8=Paudel |first8=K. |last9=Ranade |first9=S. |name-list-style=amp |date=2012 |title=The Population Decline of Gyps Vultures in India and Nepal Has Slowed since Veterinary Use of Diclofenac was Banned |journal=PLOS ONE |volume=7 |issue=11 |pages=e49118 |doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0049118 |pmc=3492300 |pmid=23145090 |bibcode=2012PLoSO...749118P|doi-access=free }}</ref> The sudden collapse of the natural animal disposal system in India has had multiple consequences negatively impacting public health.<ref>{{Cite news |title=The sudden demise of Indian vultures killed thousands of people |newspaper=The Economist |url=https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2023/08/22/the-sudden-demise-of-indian-vultures-killed-thousands-of-people |access-date=23 August 2023|issn=0013-0613}}</ref> A vulture's [[metabolism]] is a true "dead-end" for pathogens, but dogs and rats become carriers of the pathogens.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.livescience.com/48899-vultures-bacteria-microbiome.html|title=Vultures bacteria biome|date=25 November 2014|publisher=livescience.com|access-date=18 February 2016}}</ref> Without vultures, a large number of animal carcasses were left to rot posing a serious risk to human health by providing a potential breeding ground for infectious germs and proliferation of pests such as rats.<ref name="Catastrophic collapse of Indian whi"/>


The diseases carried by these mammals from rotting carcasses are indirectly responsible for thousands of human deaths.{{sfn|Rana|Prakash|2003|p=116}} The carcasses formerly eaten by vultures rot in village fields also contaminating water sources. The loss of vultures also resulted in a substantial increase in the population of feral dogs, whose bites are the most common cause of human [[rabies]]. The feral dog population in India increased by least 5 million, resulting in over 38 million additional dog bites and more than 47,000 extra deaths from rabies, costing $34 billion in economic impact.<ref name="Cam"/><ref>{{citation |author=Sudarshan MK |title=Assessing burden of rabies in India |work=WHO sponsored national multi-centric rabies survey |year=2004 |publisher=Assoc Prev Control Rabies India}}</ref> On average, it was estimated that human [[mortality rate]]s increased by more than 4% during the period of 2000 to 2005, when vulture population reached the lowest levels.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://voxdev.org/topic/energy-environment/how-human-and-ecosystem-health-are-intertwined-evidence-vulture-population-collapse-india|title=How human and ecosystem health are intertwined: Evidence from vulture population collapse in India|date=15 January 2023|access-date=23 August 2023|publisher=Voxdev}}</ref>
The diseases carried by these mammals from rotting carcasses are indirectly responsible for thousands of human deaths.{{sfn|Rana|Prakash|2003|p=116}} The carcasses formerly eaten by vultures rot in village fields also contaminating water sources. The loss of vultures also resulted in a substantial increase in the population of feral dogs, whose bites are the most common cause of human [[rabies]]. The feral dog population in India increased by least 5 million, resulting in over 38 million additional dog bites and more than 47,000 extra deaths from rabies, costing $34 billion in economic impact.<ref name="Cam"/><ref>{{citation |author=Sudarshan MK |title=Assessing burden of rabies in India |work=WHO sponsored national multi-centric rabies survey |year=2004 |publisher=Assoc Prev Control Rabies India}}</ref> On average, it was estimated that human [[mortality rate]]s increased by more than 4% during the period of 2000 to 2005, when vulture population reached the lowest levels.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://voxdev.org/topic/energy-environment/how-human-and-ecosystem-health-are-intertwined-evidence-vulture-population-collapse-india|title=How human and ecosystem health are intertwined: Evidence from vulture population collapse in India|date=15 January 2023|access-date=23 August 2023|publisher=Voxdev}}</ref>
Line 34: Line 34:


=== Diclofenac regulation ===
=== Diclofenac regulation ===
Following the findings on [[diclofenac]], the drug was banned for veterinary use in India on March 11, 2006; [[Nepal]] followed suit in August and [[Pakistan]] in October. [[Bangladesh]] banned it in 2010. A replacement drug was quickly developed and proposed after tests on vultures in captivity: [[Meloxicam]]. [[Meloxicam]], another NSAID was rapidly metabolized and harmless to vultures was suggested as an acceptable substitute for diclofenac.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1532045618301935|title=Percentage of faecal excretion of meloxicam in the Cape vultures (Gyps corprotheres)|date=1 January 2019|publisher=Science Direct|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref> Pharmaceutical companies were encouraged to the increase in the production of meloxicam aimed at reducing the cost down to diclofenac's own levels to make it more suitable for use. In 2015, Government of India ordered the vial size of the drugs to be reduced to 3ml to reduce the dosage administered to cattle.<ref name="Gu"/>
Following the findings on [[diclofenac]], the drug was banned for veterinary use in India on March 11, 2006; [[Nepal]] followed suit in August and [[Pakistan]] in October. [[Bangladesh]] banned it in 2010. A replacement drug was quickly developed and proposed after tests on vultures in captivity: [[Meloxicam]]. [[Meloxicam]], another NSAID was rapidly metabolized and harmless to vultures was suggested as an acceptable substitute for diclofenac.<ref name="Science Direct"/> Pharmaceutical companies were encouraged to the increase in the production of meloxicam aimed at reducing the cost down to diclofenac's own levels to make it more suitable for use. In 2015, Government of India ordered the vial size of the drugs to be reduced to 3ml to reduce the dosage administered to cattle.<ref name="Gu"/>


Some other drugs developed as alternatives to diclofenac — [[aceclofenac]], [[ketoprofen]] and [[nimesulide]] — have also been shown to be toxic to vultures.<ref name="Tri"/><ref>{{Cite web |title=Drug debacle: Diclofenac was not the last threat for India's vultures |url=https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/wildlife-biodiversity/drug-debacle-diclofenac-was-not-the-last-threat-for-india-s-vultures-82075 |access-date=2023-07-07 |website=www.downtoearth.org.in |language=en}}</ref> Diclofenac for human use was still being diverted into veterinary uses through illegal sale of multidose vials intended for humans for use in cattle in 2011.<ref name=":0">{{Cite journal |last1=Galligan |first1=Toby H. |last2=Mallord |first2=John W. |last3=Prakash |first3=Vibhu M. |last4=Bhusal |first4=Krishna P. |last5=Alam |first5=A. B. M. Sarowar |last6=Anthony |first6=Fergus M. |last7=Dave |first7=Ruchi |last8=Dube |first8=Alka |last9=Shastri |first9=Kartik |last10=Kumar |first10=Yogesh |last11=Prakash |first11=Nikita |last12=Ranade |first12=Sachin |last13=Shringarpure |first13=Rohan |last14=Chapagain |first14=Devendra |last15=Chaudhary |first15=Ishwary P. |date=September 2021 |title=Trends in the availability of the vulture-toxic drug, diclofenac, and other NSAIDs in South Asia, as revealed by covert pharmacy surveys |url=https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bird-conservation-international/article/trends-in-the-availability-of-the-vulturetoxic-drug-diclofenac-and-other-nsaids-in-south-asia-as-revealed-by-covert-pharmacy-surveys/B8AD82F61B5361043EDE0EBB61952931 |journal=Bird Conservation International |language=en |volume=31 |issue=3 |pages=337–353 |doi=10.1017/S0959270920000477 |s2cid=225272971 |issn=0959-2709|doi-access=free }}</ref> The ban was strengthened by the ban of vials larger than a single human dose (3 ml) in 2015, but vials were still manufactured illegally. While the ban on diclofenac has been successful in Nepal and Bangladesh, it is still widely available in India.<ref>{{Cite web |title=Despite ban, vulture-killing drug diclofenac widely sold for veterinary use in India |url=https://researchmatters.in/news/despite-ban-vulture-killing-drug-diclofenac-widely-sold-veterinary-use-india |access-date=7 July 2023|website=Research Matters |language=en}}</ref> A study published in 2020 showed that meloxicam was the most common veterinary NSAID in Nepal in 2017 (89.9%). Although diclofenac was almost entirely absent from pharmacies in Bangladesh, there was a higher proportion of sales of ketoprofen compared to meloxicam in 2018, despite the partial ban on ketoprofen by the Bangladeshi government in 2016.<ref name=":0" /> In 2021, [[tolfenamic acid]] was identified as another alternative that is safe for vultures.<ref>{{cite news|url=https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/2nd-vulture-safe-veterinary-pain-killer-drug-identified/articleshow/86101660.cms|publisher=[[Times of India]]|title=2nd vulture-safe veterinary pain-killer drug identified|author=Vijay Pinjarkar|date=11 September 2021|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>
Some other drugs developed as alternatives to diclofenac — [[aceclofenac]], [[ketoprofen]] and [[nimesulide]] — have also been shown to be toxic to vultures.<ref name="Tri"/><ref>{{Cite web |title=Drug debacle: Diclofenac was not the last threat for India's vultures |url=https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/wildlife-biodiversity/drug-debacle-diclofenac-was-not-the-last-threat-for-india-s-vultures-82075 |access-date=2023-07-07 |website=www.downtoearth.org.in |language=en}}</ref> Diclofenac for human use was still being diverted into veterinary uses through illegal sale of multidose vials intended for humans for use in cattle in 2011.<ref name=":0">{{Cite journal |last1=Galligan |first1=Toby H. |last2=Mallord |first2=John W. |last3=Prakash |first3=Vibhu M. |last4=Bhusal |first4=Krishna P. |last5=Alam |first5=A. B. M. Sarowar |last6=Anthony |first6=Fergus M. |last7=Dave |first7=Ruchi |last8=Dube |first8=Alka |last9=Shastri |first9=Kartik |last10=Kumar |first10=Yogesh |last11=Prakash |first11=Nikita |last12=Ranade |first12=Sachin |last13=Shringarpure |first13=Rohan |last14=Chapagain |first14=Devendra |last15=Chaudhary |first15=Ishwary P. |date=September 2021 |title=Trends in the availability of the vulture-toxic drug, diclofenac, and other NSAIDs in South Asia, as revealed by covert pharmacy surveys |url=https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bird-conservation-international/article/trends-in-the-availability-of-the-vulturetoxic-drug-diclofenac-and-other-nsaids-in-south-asia-as-revealed-by-covert-pharmacy-surveys/B8AD82F61B5361043EDE0EBB61952931 |journal=Bird Conservation International |language=en |volume=31 |issue=3 |pages=337–353 |doi=10.1017/S0959270920000477 |s2cid=225272971 |issn=0959-2709|doi-access=free }}</ref> The ban was strengthened by the ban of vials larger than a single human dose (3 ml) in 2015, but vials were still manufactured illegally. While the ban on diclofenac has been successful in Nepal and Bangladesh, it is still widely available in India.<ref>{{Cite web |title=Despite ban, vulture-killing drug diclofenac widely sold for veterinary use in India |url=https://researchmatters.in/news/despite-ban-vulture-killing-drug-diclofenac-widely-sold-veterinary-use-india |access-date=7 July 2023|website=Research Matters |language=en}}</ref> A study published in 2020 showed that meloxicam was the most common veterinary NSAID in Nepal in 2017 (89.9%). Although diclofenac was almost entirely absent from pharmacies in Bangladesh, there was a higher proportion of sales of ketoprofen compared to meloxicam in 2018, despite the partial ban on ketoprofen by the Bangladeshi government in 2016.<ref name=":0" /> In 2021, [[tolfenamic acid]] was identified as another alternative that is safe for vultures.<ref>{{cite news|url=https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/2nd-vulture-safe-veterinary-pain-killer-drug-identified/articleshow/86101660.cms|publisher=[[Times of India]]|title=2nd vulture-safe veterinary pain-killer drug identified|author=Vijay Pinjarkar|date=11 September 2021|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>
Line 49: Line 49:
In 2014, ''Saving Asia's Vultures from Extinction'' programme was announced to start releasing captive-bred birds into the wild by 2016.<ref>{{cite news|last=Kinver|first=M. |title=Project targets 2016 for Asian vultures release|url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-25963100|access-date=2 February 2014 |newspaper=BBC News|date=31 Jan 2014}}</ref> In 2016, [[Jatayu Conservation Breeding Centre, Pinjore|Jatayu Conservation Breeding Centre]] in [[Pinjore]] released captive bred vultures into the wild as part of Asia's first vulture re-introduction program.<ref>{{cite web|title=Asia's first vulture re-introduction programme launched in Haryana|url=http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/asias-first-vulture-re-introduction-programe-launched-in-haryana/1/683586.html}}</ref> Small numbers of birds have bred across peninsular India, in [[Karnataka]] and [[Tamil Nadu]].<ref name="Hindu">{{cite news|url=http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/longbilled-vultures-sighted-after-40-years/article5322851.ece|title=Long-billed Vulture sighted after 40 years|newspaper=The Hindu|date=7 November 2013 |first = P. |last = Oppili|access-date = 11 August 2014}}</ref> Three more breeding centers have been set up in the Indian states of [[West Bengal]], [[Assam]] and [[Madhya Pradesh]] in addition to four smaller facilities in collaboration with zoos.<ref name="Gu"/>
In 2014, ''Saving Asia's Vultures from Extinction'' programme was announced to start releasing captive-bred birds into the wild by 2016.<ref>{{cite news|last=Kinver|first=M. |title=Project targets 2016 for Asian vultures release|url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-25963100|access-date=2 February 2014 |newspaper=BBC News|date=31 Jan 2014}}</ref> In 2016, [[Jatayu Conservation Breeding Centre, Pinjore|Jatayu Conservation Breeding Centre]] in [[Pinjore]] released captive bred vultures into the wild as part of Asia's first vulture re-introduction program.<ref>{{cite web|title=Asia's first vulture re-introduction programme launched in Haryana|url=http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/asias-first-vulture-re-introduction-programe-launched-in-haryana/1/683586.html}}</ref> Small numbers of birds have bred across peninsular India, in [[Karnataka]] and [[Tamil Nadu]].<ref name="Hindu">{{cite news|url=http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/longbilled-vultures-sighted-after-40-years/article5322851.ece|title=Long-billed Vulture sighted after 40 years|newspaper=The Hindu|date=7 November 2013 |first = P. |last = Oppili|access-date = 11 August 2014}}</ref> Three more breeding centers have been set up in the Indian states of [[West Bengal]], [[Assam]] and [[Madhya Pradesh]] in addition to four smaller facilities in collaboration with zoos.<ref name="Gu"/>


In 2020, the [[Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change]] of Government of India has launched a Vulture Action Plan 2020-25. It aims to step up conservation measures and set up a mechanism to ensure that toxic drugs other than diclofenac are also banned for veterinary use.<ref name="Tri">{{cite news|url=https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/himachal/diclofenac-threat-to-7-vulture-species-477388|title=Diclofenac threat to 7 vulture species|publisher=Tribune India|date=7 February 2023|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>
In 2020, the [[Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change]] of Government of India has launched a Vulture Action Plan 2020–25. It aims to step up conservation measures and set up a mechanism to ensure that toxic drugs other than diclofenac are also banned for veterinary use.<ref name="Tri">{{cite news|url=https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/himachal/diclofenac-threat-to-7-vulture-species-477388|title=Diclofenac threat to 7 vulture species|publisher=Tribune India|date=7 February 2023|access-date=23 August 2023}}</ref>


== See also ==
== See also ==

Revision as of 23:01, 30 December 2023

The white-rumped vulture, one of the species devastated in the crisis
A flock of endangered White-rumped and Indian vultures

Nine species of vulture can be found living in India, but most are now in danger of extinction after a rapid and major population collapse in recent decades.[1][2] In the early 1980s, three species of Gyps vultures (the white-rumped vulture, the long-billed vulture and the slender-billed vulture) had a combined estimated population of 40 million in South Asia, while in 2017 the total population numbered only 19,000 (6,000, 12,000, and 1,000 respectively).

With a loss of over 99% of all the population of vultures, the Indian vulture crisis represents the sharpest decline of any animal in the given period.[3] A major contributing factor in declining populations of vultures is believed to be the widespread use of drugs such as diclofenac, a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) once commonly given to livestock. The drug is believed to have been passed onto the vultures through the flesh of dead cattle who were given diclofenac in their last days of life, which then causes kidney failure in vultures.[4] Data modelling revealed that a tiny proportion (about 0.8%) of livestock carcasses containing diclofenac can cause significant crash in vulture populations.[5]

Without vultures, a large number of animal carcasses were left to rot, posing a serious risk to human health by providing a potential breeding ground for infectious germs and proliferation of pests such as rats.[6] The loss of vultures also resulted in a substantial increase in the population of feral dogs, whose bites are the most common cause of human rabies. The feral dog population in India increased by least 5 million, resulting in over 38 million additional dog bites and more than 47,000 extra deaths from rabies, costing $34 billion in economic impact.[4]

Veterinary usage of diclofenac has been banned in India since 2006.[7][8] Meloxicam, another NSAID, which was rapidly metabolized and harmless to vultures, was suggested as an acceptable substitute for diclofenac.[9] In addition, various conservation schemes are in place to help recover the vulture population.[10] The population is recovering slowly and the decline has been significantly arrested in India, Pakistan and Nepal following a strict ban on the drugs causing harm to the vultures.[11][4][12]

History

Vultures in India live in communities and are generally very dependent on human activities. The Hindu religion, which represents 80% of the country's population,[13] is particularly favorable to vultures. Cows are considered sacred by majority of Hindus, so cow meat is generally not consumed. This results in the cow's corpse being left to be fed on by vultures. Of the estimated 500 million cattle in India, only 4% were destined for consumption by humans as meat.[14][15] Vultures constituted the natural animal disposal system, processing carcasses and nearly 15,000 vultures have been observed at the carcass depositories in capital New Delhi.[16]

Decline

In the 1990s, a decrease in the number of vultures was noted by Vibhu Prakash of the Bombay Natural History Society, who had monitored vulture populations at Keoladeo National Park.[17][18] As the decline accelerated, the international scientific community attempted to investigate the cause of such decline. However, it was not easy to examine this issue because vultures could not legally be killed for scientific study in India, and freshly dead animals had become extremely rare, a situation exacerbated by the extremely hot weather in India where temperatures before the monsoon routinely exceed 40 °C (104 °F). In 2002, National Geographic reported that scientists were "not sure" of the reason for the 95% population decline.[19] Andrew Cunningham of the Zoological Society of London found that the usual suspects of pesticide poisoning, industrial pollutants or bacteria did not show anything abnormal in the vultures he could examine, and suspected a new type of toxin exposure.[20]

Causes

In 2003, after research on the possible viral causes of the decline, the culprit was discovered by Dr. Lindsay Oaks and his team at The Peregrine Fund to be diclofenac.[21] Diclofenac is a common anti-inflammatory drug administered to livestock and is used to treat the symptoms of inflammation, fevers and/or pain associated with disease or wounds. It was widely used in India beginning in the 1990s. The drug is fatal to vultures, however, and a vulture gets exposed to a mortal dose of diclofenac on eating from the carcass of an animal that had been treated with diclofenac recently.[22] A simulation model demonstrated that if only 1% of carcasses were contaminated by diclofenac, Indian vulture populations would fall by between 60% and 90% annually, and a study of carcasses showed that about 10% were contaminated.[23]

A genus of vultures called Gyps was the most affected by diclofenac.[24] The population of the white-rumped vulture (Gyps bengalensis) fell 99.7% between 1993 and 2002. The populations of the Indian vulture (Gyps indicus) and the slender-billed vulture (Gyps tenuirostris) fell 97.4%. The percentages differ slightly because the white-rumped vulture is more sensitive to diclofenac than the other two species, but all three were in danger of extinction.[25] Two other species of Gyps, the Himalayan vulture (Gyps himalayensis) and the Eurasian griffon (Gyps fulvus) were less affected, the Eurasian griffon because it only winters in India and has a much smaller initial population, and the Himalayan vulture, with a similarly small population, because it is exclusively mountain-dwelling.[26]

Consequences

By removing all carrion, vultures had helped decrease pollution, spread of diseases, and suppressed undesirable mammalian scavengers.[27] The sudden collapse of the natural animal disposal system in India has had multiple consequences negatively impacting public health.[28] A vulture's metabolism is a true "dead-end" for pathogens, but dogs and rats become carriers of the pathogens.[29] Without vultures, a large number of animal carcasses were left to rot posing a serious risk to human health by providing a potential breeding ground for infectious germs and proliferation of pests such as rats.[6]

The diseases carried by these mammals from rotting carcasses are indirectly responsible for thousands of human deaths.[30] The carcasses formerly eaten by vultures rot in village fields also contaminating water sources. The loss of vultures also resulted in a substantial increase in the population of feral dogs, whose bites are the most common cause of human rabies. The feral dog population in India increased by least 5 million, resulting in over 38 million additional dog bites and more than 47,000 extra deaths from rabies, costing $34 billion in economic impact.[4][31] On average, it was estimated that human mortality rates increased by more than 4% during the period of 2000 to 2005, when vulture population reached the lowest levels.[32]

The people of Parsi community in India leave the dead bodies exposed in high towers called Towers of Silence in order for the vultures to feed. Due to the decline in vulture population, they have been forced to drop these ancient customs for reasons of hygiene, since now bodies take six months to disappear.[33]

Reaction

Diclofenac available in 2009

Diclofenac regulation

Following the findings on diclofenac, the drug was banned for veterinary use in India on March 11, 2006; Nepal followed suit in August and Pakistan in October. Bangladesh banned it in 2010. A replacement drug was quickly developed and proposed after tests on vultures in captivity: Meloxicam. Meloxicam, another NSAID was rapidly metabolized and harmless to vultures was suggested as an acceptable substitute for diclofenac.[9] Pharmaceutical companies were encouraged to the increase in the production of meloxicam aimed at reducing the cost down to diclofenac's own levels to make it more suitable for use. In 2015, Government of India ordered the vial size of the drugs to be reduced to 3ml to reduce the dosage administered to cattle.[5]

Some other drugs developed as alternatives to diclofenac — aceclofenac, ketoprofen and nimesulide — have also been shown to be toxic to vultures.[34][35] Diclofenac for human use was still being diverted into veterinary uses through illegal sale of multidose vials intended for humans for use in cattle in 2011.[36] The ban was strengthened by the ban of vials larger than a single human dose (3 ml) in 2015, but vials were still manufactured illegally. While the ban on diclofenac has been successful in Nepal and Bangladesh, it is still widely available in India.[37] A study published in 2020 showed that meloxicam was the most common veterinary NSAID in Nepal in 2017 (89.9%). Although diclofenac was almost entirely absent from pharmacies in Bangladesh, there was a higher proportion of sales of ketoprofen compared to meloxicam in 2018, despite the partial ban on ketoprofen by the Bangladeshi government in 2016.[36] In 2021, tolfenamic acid was identified as another alternative that is safe for vultures.[38]

Despite the vulture crisis, diclofenac remains available in other countries including many in Europe.[39] It was controversially approved for veterinary use in Spain in 2013 and continues to be available, despite Spain being home to around 90% of the European vulture population and an independent simulation showing that the drug could reduce the population of vultures by 1–8% annually. Spain's medicine agency presented simulations suggesting that the number of deaths would be quite small.[40] New sanitary regulation laws regarding animal carcass disposal in Spain also reduce the amount of available food for vultures while adding to costs and greenhouse gas emissions.[41]

Despite this regulation of Indian access to diclofenac, vultures have continued to die of diclofenac poisoning. In a study of corpses collected between 2011 and 2014, 14 out of 29 white-backed vultures and 9 out of 12 Himalayan griffon had high enough levels of diclofenac in their kidney tissue that it is likely diclofenac poisoning was their cause of death.[42] Nevertheless, there are indications that the diclofenac ban has decreased the speed of decline.[43]

Conservation

Captive-breeding programmes for the Indian vulture were started to help recover its numbers. As the vultures are long lived, slow breeding and notoriously difficult to breed in captivity, the programmes are expected to take longer. The captive-bred birds will be released to the wild when the environment is clear of diclofenac.

In 2002, the Parsis had asked the International Centre for Birds of Prey for assistance with vulture breeding.[19]

In 2014, Saving Asia's Vultures from Extinction programme was announced to start releasing captive-bred birds into the wild by 2016.[44] In 2016, Jatayu Conservation Breeding Centre in Pinjore released captive bred vultures into the wild as part of Asia's first vulture re-introduction program.[45] Small numbers of birds have bred across peninsular India, in Karnataka and Tamil Nadu.[46] Three more breeding centers have been set up in the Indian states of West Bengal, Assam and Madhya Pradesh in addition to four smaller facilities in collaboration with zoos.[5]

In 2020, the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change of Government of India has launched a Vulture Action Plan 2020–25. It aims to step up conservation measures and set up a mechanism to ensure that toxic drugs other than diclofenac are also banned for veterinary use.[34]

See also

Notes

  1. ^ "IUCN red list". IUCN. Archived from the original on June 27, 2014. Retrieved 13 August 2015.
  2. ^ "Conserving South Asia's Threatened Vultures". Save Our Species. Retrieved 13 August 2015.
  3. ^ "Sharp decline in vulture population, from 40 million to 19,000: Prakash Javadekar". The Hindu. 19 July 2019. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  4. ^ a b c d Ian Burfield; Chris Bowden (28 September 2022). "South Asian vultures and diclofenac". Cambridge University. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  5. ^ a b c Kamakshi Iyer (19 August 2021). "Born to be wild: India's first captive-bred endangered vultures set free". The Guardian. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  6. ^ a b Prakash, V.; Pain, D.J.; Cunningham, A.A.; Donald, P.F.; Prakash, N.; Verma, A.; Gargi, R.; Sivakumar, S. & Rahmani, A.R. (2003). "Catastrophic collapse of Indian white-backed Gyps bengalensis and long-billed Gyps indicus vulture populations". Biological Conservation. 109 (3): 381–390. doi:10.1016/S0006-3207(02)00164-7.
  7. ^ "Diclofenac Ban".
  8. ^ "Indian courts ban multi-dose vials of Diclofenac – another step in the right direction to save Southern Asia vultures from extinction". Vulture Conservation Foundation. 4 November 2017. Retrieved 25 June 2020.
  9. ^ a b "Percentage of faecal excretion of meloxicam in the Cape vultures (Gyps corprotheres)". Science Direct. 1 January 2019. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  10. ^ Kinver, M. (31 Jan 2014). "Project targets 2016 for Asian vultures release". BBC News. Retrieved 2 February 2014.
  11. ^ "Indian Vulture factsheet". birdlife.org. Retrieved 25 August 2023.
  12. ^ Rajat Ghai (17 January 2019). "Madhya Pradesh's vulture population increases". Times of India. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  13. ^ Indian statistics, 2001
  14. ^ ILC 2003, projection based on Animal Husbandry Statistics, Government of India.
  15. ^ FAO, 2003
  16. ^ Greenwood 1938, p. 234.
  17. ^ Rana & Prakash 2003, p. 116–117.
  18. ^ Prakash 1988, p. 614–615.
  19. ^ a b Research Correspondence staff (July 2002). "Ask Us". National Geographic. p. 3.
  20. ^ McGrath, Susan (1 February 2007), The Vanishing, Smithsonian Magazine
  21. ^ Oaks et al. 2004, p. 630.
  22. ^ Oaks et al. 2004, p. 5909–5912.
  23. ^ Green et al. 2004, p. 793–800.
  24. ^ Johnson et al. 2006, p. 65.
  25. ^ Swan, GE; Cuthbert, R; Quevedo, M; et al. (June 2006). "Diclofenac effect". Biol. Lett. 2 (2): 279–82. doi:10.1098/rsbl.2005.0425. PMC 1618889. PMID 17148382.
  26. ^ Grimmett, Richard; Inskipp, Carol; Inskipp, Tim (2016). Birds of the Indian Subcontinent: India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh and the Maldives. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 110. ISBN 978-1-4081-6265-1.
  27. ^ Prakash, V.; Bishwakarma, M. C.; Chaudhary, A.; Cuthbert, R.; Dave, R.; Kulkarni, M.; Kumar, S.; Paudel, K. & Ranade, S. (2012). "The Population Decline of Gyps Vultures in India and Nepal Has Slowed since Veterinary Use of Diclofenac was Banned". PLOS ONE. 7 (11): e49118. Bibcode:2012PLoSO...749118P. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049118. PMC 3492300. PMID 23145090.
  28. ^ "The sudden demise of Indian vultures killed thousands of people". The Economist. ISSN 0013-0613. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  29. ^ "Vultures bacteria biome". livescience.com. 25 November 2014. Retrieved 18 February 2016.
  30. ^ Rana & Prakash 2003, p. 116.
  31. ^ Sudarshan MK (2004), "Assessing burden of rabies in India", WHO sponsored national multi-centric rabies survey, Assoc Prev Control Rabies India
  32. ^ "How human and ecosystem health are intertwined: Evidence from vulture population collapse in India". Voxdev. 15 January 2023. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  33. ^ "Death in the city: How a lack of vultures threatens Mumbai's 'Towers of Silence'". The Guardian. 26 January 2015. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  34. ^ a b "Diclofenac threat to 7 vulture species". Tribune India. 7 February 2023. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  35. ^ "Drug debacle: Diclofenac was not the last threat for India's vultures". www.downtoearth.org.in. Retrieved 2023-07-07.
  36. ^ a b Galligan, Toby H.; Mallord, John W.; Prakash, Vibhu M.; Bhusal, Krishna P.; Alam, A. B. M. Sarowar; Anthony, Fergus M.; Dave, Ruchi; Dube, Alka; Shastri, Kartik; Kumar, Yogesh; Prakash, Nikita; Ranade, Sachin; Shringarpure, Rohan; Chapagain, Devendra; Chaudhary, Ishwary P. (September 2021). "Trends in the availability of the vulture-toxic drug, diclofenac, and other NSAIDs in South Asia, as revealed by covert pharmacy surveys". Bird Conservation International. 31 (3): 337–353. doi:10.1017/S0959270920000477. ISSN 0959-2709. S2CID 225272971.
  37. ^ "Despite ban, vulture-killing drug diclofenac widely sold for veterinary use in India". Research Matters. Retrieved 7 July 2023.
  38. ^ Vijay Pinjarkar (11 September 2021). "2nd vulture-safe veterinary pain-killer drug identified". Times of India. Retrieved 23 August 2023.
  39. ^ "E-010588/2015: answer given by Mr Andriukaitis on behalf of the Commission". European Parliament. Retrieved 2 May 2016.
  40. ^ Becker, Rachel (2016). "Cattle drug threatens thousands of vultures". Nature. doi:10.1038/nature.2016.19839. S2CID 75173071. Retrieved 2 May 2016.
  41. ^ Morales-Reyes, Zebensui; Pérez-García, Juan M.; Moleón, Marcos; Botella, Francisco; Carrete, Martina; Lazcano, Carolina; Moreno-Opo, Rubén; Margalida, Antoni; Donázar, José A. (2015-01-15). "Supplanting ecosystem services provided by scavengers raises greenhouse gas emissions". Scientific Reports. 5 (1): 7811. Bibcode:2015NatSR...5E7811M. doi:10.1038/srep07811. ISSN 2045-2322. PMC 4295086. PMID 25589381.
  42. ^ Nambirajan, Kanthan; Muralidharan, Subramanian; Roy, Aditya A.; Manonmani, S. (February 2018). "Residues of Diclofenac in Tissues of Vultures in India: A Post-ban Scenario". Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. 74 (2): 292–297. doi:10.1007/s00244-017-0480-z. ISSN 1432-0703. PMID 29159701. S2CID 46827639.
  43. ^ Prakash, Vibhu; Bishwakarma, Mohan Chandra; Chaudhary, Anand; Cuthbert, Richard; Dave, Ruchi; Kulkarni, Mandar; Kumar, Sashi; Paudel, Khadananda; Ranade, Sachin; Shringarpure, Rohan; Green, Rhys E. (2012). "The population decline of Gyps vultures in India and Nepal has slowed since veterinary use of diclofenac was banned". PLOS ONE. 7 (11): e49118. Bibcode:2012PLoSO...749118P. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0049118. ISSN 1932-6203. PMC 3492300. PMID 23145090.
  44. ^ Kinver, M. (31 Jan 2014). "Project targets 2016 for Asian vultures release". BBC News. Retrieved 2 February 2014.
  45. ^ "Asia's first vulture re-introduction programme launched in Haryana".
  46. ^ Oppili, P. (7 November 2013). "Long-billed Vulture sighted after 40 years". The Hindu. Retrieved 11 August 2014.

References

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Indian_vulture_crisis&oldid=1192715163"