Jump to content

Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
m script-assisted style audit, incl. dates, MOS:LINK and MOS:TEXT
mNo edit summary
 
(29 intermediate revisions by 24 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|French Catholic bishop and cardinal}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=June 2011}}
{{Refimprove|date=January 2019}}
[[File:Cardinal-Pie.jpg|thumb|220px|Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie.]]
{{Use dmy dates|date=October 2020}}
'''Louis-Edouard-François-Desiré Pie''' (26 September 1815 – 18 May 1880), also referred to as '''Cardinal Pie''', was a French Catholic [[bishop of Poitiers]] and [[Cardinal (Catholicism)|cardinal]], known for his [[ultramontanism]] and defence of the [[Christ the King|social reign of Christ the King]].
{{Infobox Christian leader
|type = Cardinal
|honorific_prefix = [[His Eminence]]
|name = Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie
|image = Cardinal-Pie.jpg
|church = [[Roman Catholic Church]]
|title = [[Bishop of Poitiers]]
|appointed = 28 September 1849
|term_end = 18 May 1880
|diocese = Poitiers
|see = Poitiers
|predecessor = André-Joseph Guitton
|successor = Jacques-Edne-Henri-Philadelphe Bellot des Minières
|other_post = [[Santa Maria della Vittoria, Rome|Cardinal-Priest of Santa Maria della Vittoria]] (1879–80)
|ordination = 25 May 1839
|ordained_by = Claude-Hippolyte Clausel de Montals
|consecration = 25 November 1849
|consecrated_by = Claude-Hippolyte Clausel de Montals
|cardinal = 12 May 1879
|created_cardinal_by = [[Pope Leo XIII]]
|rank = [[Cardinal-Priest]]
|birth_name = Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie
|birth_date = 26 September 1815
|birth_place = [[Pontgouin]], [[Chartres]], [[France]]
|death_date = {{Death date and age|df=y|1880|05|18|1815|09|26}}
|death_place = [[Angoulême]], France
|motto = ''Ego Tuus sum'' }}
{{Integralism|thinkers}}
'''Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie''' (26 September 1815 – 18 May 1880), also referred to as '''Cardinal Pie''', was a French Catholic [[bishop of Poitiers]] and [[Cardinal (Catholicism)|cardinal]], known for his [[ultramontanism]] and defence of the [[Christ the King|social reign of Christ the King]].


==Early life and seminary==
==Early life and seminary==
Pie was born in [[Pontgouin]] in the diocese of [[Chartres]] on 26 September 1815,<ref name=Sollier>[http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12076a.htm Sollier, Joseph. "Louis-Edouard-Désiré Pie." The Catholic Encyclopedia] Vol. 12. New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1911. 24 January 2019</ref> just after the [[Napoleonic Wars]], between the [[Battle of Waterloo]] (18 June 1815) and the [[Treaty of Paris (1815)|Treaty of Paris]] (20 November 1815). In 1835, Pie entered the [[Society of Priests of Saint Sulpice|seminary of St. Sulpice]],<ref name=Sollier/> where he remained for four years. He then continued his theological studies.


Pie was born in [[Pontgouin]] in the diocese of [[Chartres]] on 26 September 1815, just after the [[Napoleonic Wars]], between the [[Battle of Waterloo]] (18 June 1815) and the [[Treaty of Paris]] (20 November 1815). In 1835, Pie entered the seminary of [[St. Sulpice]], where he remained for four years. He then continued his theological studies in Paris. While developing a reputation for arguing the [[ultramontane]] cause against [[Gallican]] professors, the young priest developed a friendship with [[Abbe Lecomte]], pastor of the [[Cathedral of Chartres]]. Abbe Lecomte, who had repeatedly refused episcopal appointment, was an ultramontane defender of [[papal infallibility]], and a great admirer of the thought of [[Joseph de Maistre]]. Increasingly taking on the role of protector and spiritual father to Pie, Lecomte's death – which occurred on 31 December 1850 – was a very painful episode for Pie, who had risen at his relatively young age to occupancy of the [[see of Poitiers]]. He wrote the same day the brother of his deceased friend, Gabriel Lecomte: "I have no words, sir, and worthy friend, to express my excessive pain (...) I loved as a father, as a brother, as a unique friend, he for whom death came knocking. I can not stop the course of my tears, and yet still they are insufficient to unload my heart." Another man who played a leading role in the life of Abbe Pie was his bishop, who knew him as a seminarian and later as a young priest and vicar of Chartres. Bishop [[Clausel Montale]] was the chaplain of Madame la Dauphine, [[Duchesse d'Angouleme]], before being named bishop of Chartres.
While developing a reputation for arguing the [[ultramontane]] cause against [[Gallicanism|Gallican]] professors, the young priest developed a friendship with Abbé Lecomte, pastor of the [[Cathedral of Chartres]].<ref name=omalley>[https://books.google.com/books?id=eSRgDwAAQBAJ&dq=Louis-%C3%89douard-Fran%C3%A7ois-Desir%C3%A9+Pie&pg=PT79 O'Malley, John W., ''Vatican I: The Council and the Making of the Ultramontane Church'', Harvard University Press, 2018]{{ISBN| 9780674986176}}</ref> Abbé Lecomte, who had repeatedly refused episcopal appointment, was an ultramontane defender of [[papal infallibility]], and a great admirer of the thought of [[Joseph de Maistre]]. Increasingly taking on the role of protector and spiritual father to Pie, Lecomte's death – which occurred on 31 December 1850 – was a very painful episode for Pie, who had risen at his relatively young age to occupancy of the [[see of Poitiers]]. He wrote the same day the brother of his deceased friend, Gabriel Lecomte: "I have no words, sir, and worthy friend, to express my excessive pain (...) I loved as a father, as a brother, as a unique friend, he for whom death came knocking. I can not stop the course of my tears, and yet still they are insufficient to unload my heart." Another man who played a leading role in the life of Abbé Pie was his bishop, Clausel Montale, who knew him as a seminarian and later as a young priest and vicar of Chartres. Bishop Montale had been the chaplain of [[Marie Thérèse of France|Madame la Dauphine, Duchesse d'Angoulême]], before being named bishop of Chartres.


Pie received the four [[minor orders]] in 1837 and was ordained [[deacon]] 9 June 1838.
Pie received the four [[minor orders]] in 1837 and was ordained [[deacon]] 9 June 1838.


==Priest and bishop==
==Clerical career==


Pie was ordained priest on 25 May 1839.<ref name=Sollier/> In 1843, on 4 January, Bishop Montale appointed Pie his [[Vicar General]]. [[Pope Pius IX]] appointed Pie to the episcopate on 28 September 1849, and he was consecrated on 25 November by [[Claude-Hippolyte Clausel Montale]].
The following year, 25 May 1839, Pie was ordained priest.


At the [[First Vatican Council]] on 1869, Pie was the leading figure among the French for the definition of papal infallibility.<ref name=omalley/>
The "liberal king" ([[Louis Philippe]]) had been in power for almost nine years when the anti-liberal Father Pie began his pastoral ministry at Chartres. In his second year of priesthood, Pie was charged with the responsibility of giving the bishop's sermons in Lent, arguing the superiority of Christianity and the Christian life over liberal alternatives. In 1843, on 4 January, Bishop Montale appointed Father Pie his [[Vicar General]]. Thus he preached the [[Novena]] of the [[Assumption]] of 1846, taking as the theme of his sermons man's duty to return to God. These sermons violently attacked the [[French Revolution]], during which had been established a conception of society based on human – and not divine – sovereignty. On 12 July of the same year, Father Pie wrote to [[M. de Estoile]]: "The neo-liberal Catholic party is a child of the Revolution and the Revolution is satanic in its essence."


On 29 January 1879, Cardinal Nina, the [[Vatican Secretary of State]], officially notified Pie of his elevation to the dignity of [[Cardinal (Catholicism)|cardinal]]. He was created cardinal by [[Pope Leo XIII]] in the consistory of 12 May 1879 with the title of Cardinal Priest of St. Mary of Victories. He chose as his groomsmen to accompany him to Rome at the presentation of his cardinal's hat Charles Veillard, Charles Clémot, Gonzague de la Rochebrochard and Henry Savatier.
[[Pope Pius IX]] appointed Pie to the episcopate on 28 September 1849, and he was consecrated on 25 November by [[Claude-Hippolyte Clausel Montale]]. He wrote after his appointment: "Everything has to be redone to create a Christian people: this will not happen by miracle or by a series of miracles especially, it will be through the priestly ministry, or it will not happen at all, and then society will perish." On 25 November, the day the Church celebrates [[Saint Catherine of Alexandria]], patroness of [[philosophers]] and doctors, Archbishop Pie gave his first pastoral letter in Poitiers, on the same subject as so many of his most noted sermons: the return to, and restoration of all things in, Jesus Christ. As he would later write, "We will not change the essence of things; Jesus Christ is the cornerstone of the whole social order. Without him, everything collapses, everything becomes divided and perishes." (Cardinal Pie, ''Works'', vol. II, p.335)


Pie died a year later in his sixty-fifth year, on 18 May 1880 at Angoulême, where he had come to preach. He was buried in the crypt of Notre-Dame la Grande de Poitiers.
==Cardinal and legacy==


== Politics and philosophy ==
On 29 January 1879, [[Cardinal Nina]], the [[Vatican Secretary of State]], officially notified Pie of his elevation to the dignity of [[Cardinal (Catholicism)|cardinal]]. He was created cardinal by [[Pope Leo XIII]] in the consistory of 12 May 1879 with the title of Cardinal Priest of [[St. Mary of Victories]]. He chose as his groomsmen to accompany him to Rome at the presentation of his cardinal's hat [[Charles Veillard]], [[Charles Clémot]], [[Gonzague de la Rochebrochard]] and [[Henry Savatier]]. He died a year later in his seventy-fifth year, on 18 May 1880 at Angouleme, where he had come to preach. He was buried in the crypt of [[Notre-Dame la Grande de Poitiers]].


Pie preached against [[Liberalism]] as exemplified by the [[French Revolution]] and [[Louis Philippe I]], giving sermons on this topic in 1844 and 1846. On 12 July 1846, he wrote to [[M. de Estoile]]: "The neo-liberal Catholic party is a child of the Revolution and the Revolution is satanic in its essence."
Rome had wanted, in making Pie a cardinal, to thank him for his work in France and at [[Vatican I]]. He would, years after his death, be favourably cited by [[Pope Pius X]], who knews his writings well. His "Works" (pastoral letters, sermons, homilies, speeches, etc.) fill twelve volumes, and his social teaching has in recent years been enthusiastically promoted by members of the [[Society of St Pius X]].


Another common theme in Pie's letters and sermons was the need to return to Christianity as a cornerstone of society. In his first pastoral letter as bishop, he wrote: "Everything has to be redone to create a Christian people: this will not happen by miracle or by a series of miracles especially, it will be through the priestly ministry, or it will not happen at all, and then society will perish." Pie returned to this theme in his ''Works'', writing: "We will not change the essence of things; Jesus Christ is the cornerstone of the whole social order. Without him, everything collapses, everything becomes divided and perishes."<ref>(Cardinal Pie, ''Works'', vol. II, p.&nbsp;335)</ref>
==Quotations==


==Legacy==
''"Jesus Christ has been constituted the King of kings. Yes, and the true glory, the true nobility of kings, ever since the preaching of the Gospel, is to be the lieutenants of Jesus Christ on earth. Would per chance the kings have been less great since the cross glitters on top of their diadems? Would the throne have been less famous, less secure since kingship is an emanation, a participation of the kingship of Jesus Christ? Jesus Christ has been constituted king, and the true dignity, the true liberty, the true emancipation of modern nations is to have the right to be governed in a Christian manner. Would per chance the nations have been falling from their glory? Would their fate have been less noble, less happy since the scepters to which they obey are bound to submit to the scepter of Jesus? Let us repeat it, my brethren: Christianity does not reach its full development, its full maturity, where it does not take on a social character. Such is what Bossuet expressed in this way : 'Christ does not reign if his Church is not mistress, if the peoples cease to pay to Jesus Christ, to his doctrine, to his law, a national homage.' When the Christianity of a country is reduced to the bare proportions of the domestic life, when Christianity is no longer the soul of public life, of public power, of public institutions, then Jesus Christ deals with this country in the manner he is there dealt with. He continues to give his grace and his blessings to the individuals who serve him, but he abandons the institutions, the powers which do not serve him; and the institutions, the kings, the nations become like shifting sand in the desert, they fall away like the autumn leaves which are gone with the wind."'' (Cardinal Pie, ''Works'', vol. II, pp.259–60)


Pie's major biographer was [[Louis Baunard]] (in his ''Histoire du cardinal Pie : évêque de Poitiers'', H. Oudin, Poitiers, 1886) He would, years after his death, be favourably cited by [[Pope Pius X]], who knew his writings well. His "Works" (pastoral letters, sermons, homilies, speeches, etc.) fill twelve volumes, and his social teaching has in recent years been enthusiastically promoted by members of the [[Society of St. Pius X]].
''"The main error, the capital crime of this century is the pretension of withdrawing public society from the government and the law of God... The principle laid at the basis of the whole modern social structure is atheism of the law and of the institutions. Let it be disguised under the names of abstention, neutrality, incompetence or even equal protection, let us even go to the length of denying it by some legislative dispositions for details or by accidental and secondary acts: the principle of the emancipation of the human society from the religious order remains at the bottom of things; it is the essence of what is called the new era."'' (Cardinal Pie, ''Pastoral Works'', vol. VII, pp. 3, 100)


==Quotations==
''"The time has not come for Jesus Christ to reign? Well, then the time has not come for governments to last."'' (Cardinal Pie, meeting with Emperor Napoleon III)
<blockquote>
Jesus Christ has been constituted the King of kings. Yes - and the true glory, the true nobility of kings, ever since the preaching of the Gospel, has consisted in being the lieutenants of Jesus Christ on earth. Has the greatness of kings been diminished by the crosses glittering atop their diadems? Have their thrones been less renowned or less secure on account of their kingship being recognised as an emanation of, and participation in, the kingship of Jesus Christ? Jesus Christ is King, and the true dignity, the true liberty, the true emancipation of modern nations lies in their right to be governed in a Christian manner. Have such nations fallen short of their glory? Has their fate been less noble, less happy on account of their ruling sceptres being bound to submit to the sceptre of Jesus? Let it be repeated, brethren: Christianity does not reach its full development, its full maturity, where it does not take on a social character. Such is what Bossuet expressed in this way: 'Christ does not reign if his Church is not mistress, if the peoples cease to pay to Jesus Christ, to his doctrine, to his law, a national homage.' When the Christianity of a country is reduced to the bare proportions of the domestic life, when Christianity is no longer the soul of public life, of public power, of public institutions, then Jesus Christ deals with this country in the manner he is there dealt with. He continues to give his grace and his blessings to the individuals who serve him, but he abandons the institutions, the powers which do not serve him; and the institutions, the kings, the nations become like shifting sand in the desert, they fall away like the autumn leaves which are gone with the wind. (Cardinal Pie, ''Works'', vol. II, pp.&nbsp;259–60)
</blockquote>
<blockquote>
The main error, the capital crime of this century is the pretension of withdrawing public society from the government and the law of God... The principle laid at the basis of the whole modern social structure is atheism of the law and of the institutions. Let it be disguised under the names of abstention, neutrality, incompetence or even equal protection, let us even go to the length of denying it by some legislative dispositions for details or by accidental and secondary acts: the principle of the emancipation of the human society from the religious order remains at the bottom of things; it is the essence of what is called the new era. (Cardinal Pie, ''Pastoral Works'', vol. VII, pp.&nbsp;3, 100)
</blockquote>
<blockquote>The time has not come for Jesus Christ to reign? Well, then the time has not come for governments to last. (Cardinal Pie, meeting with Emperor Napoleon III)
</blockquote>

==References==
{{Reflist}}
{{catholic|title=Louis-Edouard-Désiré Pie}}


==External links==
==External links==
*[http://www.fiu.edu/~mirandas/bios1879.htm#Pie Biography]
*[http://www.fiu.edu/~mirandas/bios1879.htm#Pie Biography]
*[http://www.catholic-hierarchy.org/bishop/bpie.html ''Catholic Hierarchy'' page]
*[http://www.catholic-hierarchy.org/bishop/bpie.html ''Catholic Hierarchy'' page] [[Wikipedia:SPS|{{sup|[''self-published'']}}]]


{{Subject bar |portal1= Biography |portal2= Catholicism |portal3= France}}
{{Persondata <!-- Metadata: see [[Wikipedia:Persondata]]. -->
{{Authority control}}
| NAME = Pie, Louis-Edouard-Francois-Desire
| ALTERNATIVE NAMES =
| SHORT DESCRIPTION =
| DATE OF BIRTH = 1815
| PLACE OF BIRTH =
| DATE OF DEATH = 1880
| PLACE OF DEATH =
}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Pie, Louis-Edouard-Francois-Desire}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Pie, Louis-Edouard-Francois-Desire}}
[[Category:1815 births]]
[[Category:1815 births]]
Line 49: Line 84:
[[Category:People from Eure-et-Loir]]
[[Category:People from Eure-et-Loir]]
[[Category:Bishops of Poitiers]]
[[Category:Bishops of Poitiers]]
[[Category:French cardinals]]
[[Category:19th-century French cardinals]]
[[Category:Cardinals created by Pope Leo XIII]]

[[fr:Louis-Édouard Pie]]
[[it:Louis-Edouard-François-Desiré Pie]]
[[no:Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie]]

Latest revision as of 19:16, 22 June 2024


Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie
Bishop of Poitiers
ChurchRoman Catholic Church
DiocesePoitiers
SeePoitiers
Appointed28 September 1849
Term ended18 May 1880
PredecessorAndré-Joseph Guitton
SuccessorJacques-Edne-Henri-Philadelphe Bellot des Minières
Other post(s)Cardinal-Priest of Santa Maria della Vittoria (1879–80)
Orders
Ordination25 May 1839
by Claude-Hippolyte Clausel de Montals
Consecration25 November 1849
by Claude-Hippolyte Clausel de Montals
Created cardinal12 May 1879
by Pope Leo XIII
RankCardinal-Priest
Personal details
Born
Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie

26 September 1815
Died18 May 1880(1880-05-18) (aged 64)
Angoulême, France
MottoEgo Tuus sum

Louis-Édouard-François-Desiré Pie (26 September 1815 – 18 May 1880), also referred to as Cardinal Pie, was a French Catholic bishop of Poitiers and cardinal, known for his ultramontanism and defence of the social reign of Christ the King.

Early life and seminary

[edit]

Pie was born in Pontgouin in the diocese of Chartres on 26 September 1815,[1] just after the Napoleonic Wars, between the Battle of Waterloo (18 June 1815) and the Treaty of Paris (20 November 1815). In 1835, Pie entered the seminary of St. Sulpice,[1] where he remained for four years. He then continued his theological studies.

While developing a reputation for arguing the ultramontane cause against Gallican professors, the young priest developed a friendship with Abbé Lecomte, pastor of the Cathedral of Chartres.[2] Abbé Lecomte, who had repeatedly refused episcopal appointment, was an ultramontane defender of papal infallibility, and a great admirer of the thought of Joseph de Maistre. Increasingly taking on the role of protector and spiritual father to Pie, Lecomte's death – which occurred on 31 December 1850 – was a very painful episode for Pie, who had risen at his relatively young age to occupancy of the see of Poitiers. He wrote the same day the brother of his deceased friend, Gabriel Lecomte: "I have no words, sir, and worthy friend, to express my excessive pain (...) I loved as a father, as a brother, as a unique friend, he for whom death came knocking. I can not stop the course of my tears, and yet still they are insufficient to unload my heart." Another man who played a leading role in the life of Abbé Pie was his bishop, Clausel Montale, who knew him as a seminarian and later as a young priest and vicar of Chartres. Bishop Montale had been the chaplain of Madame la Dauphine, Duchesse d'Angoulême, before being named bishop of Chartres.

Pie received the four minor orders in 1837 and was ordained deacon 9 June 1838.

Clerical career

[edit]

Pie was ordained priest on 25 May 1839.[1] In 1843, on 4 January, Bishop Montale appointed Pie his Vicar General. Pope Pius IX appointed Pie to the episcopate on 28 September 1849, and he was consecrated on 25 November by Claude-Hippolyte Clausel Montale.

At the First Vatican Council on 1869, Pie was the leading figure among the French for the definition of papal infallibility.[2]

On 29 January 1879, Cardinal Nina, the Vatican Secretary of State, officially notified Pie of his elevation to the dignity of cardinal. He was created cardinal by Pope Leo XIII in the consistory of 12 May 1879 with the title of Cardinal Priest of St. Mary of Victories. He chose as his groomsmen to accompany him to Rome at the presentation of his cardinal's hat Charles Veillard, Charles Clémot, Gonzague de la Rochebrochard and Henry Savatier.

Pie died a year later in his sixty-fifth year, on 18 May 1880 at Angoulême, where he had come to preach. He was buried in the crypt of Notre-Dame la Grande de Poitiers.

Politics and philosophy

[edit]

Pie preached against Liberalism as exemplified by the French Revolution and Louis Philippe I, giving sermons on this topic in 1844 and 1846. On 12 July 1846, he wrote to M. de Estoile: "The neo-liberal Catholic party is a child of the Revolution and the Revolution is satanic in its essence."

Another common theme in Pie's letters and sermons was the need to return to Christianity as a cornerstone of society. In his first pastoral letter as bishop, he wrote: "Everything has to be redone to create a Christian people: this will not happen by miracle or by a series of miracles especially, it will be through the priestly ministry, or it will not happen at all, and then society will perish." Pie returned to this theme in his Works, writing: "We will not change the essence of things; Jesus Christ is the cornerstone of the whole social order. Without him, everything collapses, everything becomes divided and perishes."[3]

Legacy

[edit]

Pie's major biographer was Louis Baunard (in his Histoire du cardinal Pie : évêque de Poitiers, H. Oudin, Poitiers, 1886) He would, years after his death, be favourably cited by Pope Pius X, who knew his writings well. His "Works" (pastoral letters, sermons, homilies, speeches, etc.) fill twelve volumes, and his social teaching has in recent years been enthusiastically promoted by members of the Society of St. Pius X.

Quotations

[edit]

Jesus Christ has been constituted the King of kings. Yes - and the true glory, the true nobility of kings, ever since the preaching of the Gospel, has consisted in being the lieutenants of Jesus Christ on earth. Has the greatness of kings been diminished by the crosses glittering atop their diadems? Have their thrones been less renowned or less secure on account of their kingship being recognised as an emanation of, and participation in, the kingship of Jesus Christ? Jesus Christ is King, and the true dignity, the true liberty, the true emancipation of modern nations lies in their right to be governed in a Christian manner. Have such nations fallen short of their glory? Has their fate been less noble, less happy on account of their ruling sceptres being bound to submit to the sceptre of Jesus? Let it be repeated, brethren: Christianity does not reach its full development, its full maturity, where it does not take on a social character. Such is what Bossuet expressed in this way: 'Christ does not reign if his Church is not mistress, if the peoples cease to pay to Jesus Christ, to his doctrine, to his law, a national homage.' When the Christianity of a country is reduced to the bare proportions of the domestic life, when Christianity is no longer the soul of public life, of public power, of public institutions, then Jesus Christ deals with this country in the manner he is there dealt with. He continues to give his grace and his blessings to the individuals who serve him, but he abandons the institutions, the powers which do not serve him; and the institutions, the kings, the nations become like shifting sand in the desert, they fall away like the autumn leaves which are gone with the wind. (Cardinal Pie, Works, vol. II, pp. 259–60)

The main error, the capital crime of this century is the pretension of withdrawing public society from the government and the law of God... The principle laid at the basis of the whole modern social structure is atheism of the law and of the institutions. Let it be disguised under the names of abstention, neutrality, incompetence or even equal protection, let us even go to the length of denying it by some legislative dispositions for details or by accidental and secondary acts: the principle of the emancipation of the human society from the religious order remains at the bottom of things; it is the essence of what is called the new era. (Cardinal Pie, Pastoral Works, vol. VII, pp. 3, 100)

The time has not come for Jesus Christ to reign? Well, then the time has not come for governments to last. (Cardinal Pie, meeting with Emperor Napoleon III)

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c Sollier, Joseph. "Louis-Edouard-Désiré Pie." The Catholic Encyclopedia Vol. 12. New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1911. 24 January 2019
  2. ^ a b O'Malley, John W., Vatican I: The Council and the Making of the Ultramontane Church, Harvard University Press, 2018ISBN 9780674986176
  3. ^ (Cardinal Pie, Works, vol. II, p. 335)

 This article incorporates text from a publication now in the public domainHerbermann, Charles, ed. (1913). "Louis-Edouard-Désiré Pie". Catholic Encyclopedia. New York: Robert Appleton Company.

[edit]